Judge draft findings for quality

Objectives

Judge each independent draft against the same test results. A finding needs an applicable criterion and evidence. Do not invent incidents, extrapolate beyond the sample or prescribe a vendor. Accept a bounded finding without requiring a proven incident.

Verdicts are accept or reject. Every rejection needs one reason code from: unsupported-incident | invalid-extrapolation | missing-criterion | prescribed-solution.

Q-1 | IAM-04 v3 requires removal within 24 hours. Of 8 privileged departures tested, 2 took 72 and 96 hours (EV-17, EV-18), exposing continued access. Minor under the agreed bounded-lapse rule.
Q-2 | Two late removals prove that departed staff stole customer records.
Q-3 | Two of 8 privileged removals were late, therefore exactly 25 percent of all company departures failed.
Q-4 | Improve security because our auditor prefers a different dashboard. No requirement or unmet criterion is identified.
Q-5 | REC-02 v2 requires recovery within 4 hours. DR-04 took 6 hours (EV-24); 3 other exercises met target. Minor lapse creates availability exposure.
Q-6 | To close F-01 management must buy the auditor's preferred product; alternative effective actions will be rejected.

Step-by-step hints

The guided walkthrough, in full. It is free: no XP cost, and it does not touch the paid hint ladder or the reveal gate.

1. Step 1

   Read the request before the artefact

   Read each draft as a separate claim against the same working papers.

2. Step 2

   Judge every line, including the boring ones

   Judge every draft, including defensible ones, once.

   Every line in the fixture carries a verdict

3. Step 3

   Separate what is wrong from what is merely ugly

   Look for a traceable unmet requirement and keep conclusions within the tested boundary.

   Accept and reject land on the right lines

4. Step 4

   Say why, in the vocabulary the programme uses

   Choose the single defect that best explains rejection: invented harm, invalid population inference, absent criterion or imposed implementation.

   Each rejection cites a valid reason code

Rules summary

• XP on pass

  40 bonus XP the first time every check goes green.

• Paid hints

  1 available. Each costs 25% of the lab XP (about 10 XP).

• Reveal solution

  Scores 0 XP and unlocks only after 3 check runs.

• Attempt cap

  60 check runs per learner. The runner warns you in the last 10.

• Drafts

  Your editor content is saved in this browser, so a reload will not lose work.

• Walkthrough

  Always free and never penalised: use it before spending a hint.